Bismillahirrahmanirraheem
SAWAL: Agar yazid ka ahle bait ke qatl me koi haanth nahi aur yah sab kuch ibne saad wa ibne ziyaad ki shararat hai to kya yazid ka yah farz nahi tha ki wah bahuqme apne governer etc ko bulaata aur unhe ahle bait ke qatal me wah ibne ziyad badmash ko commandari se hata sakta tha??
JAWAB: Yah sawal jayez hai yazid ko yaqinan hz hussain ra ke qaatilon se hisaab karna aur unhe commandari(status) se hata dena chahiye tha,
lekin jis tarah har baadshah ki kuch political majboorian hoti hain jin ke bina par kabhi kabhi unhe apne afsaron(officers) ki kuch aisi kaarywaayi(actions) se bhi aankhen moondni(closing) pad jaati hai, jinhe wah khud bhi ghalat samjhte hain, isi tarah ho sakta hai kuch aisi siyaasi majboori ho jisko yazid ne zyada importance de diya ho jabki use qatl hussain ko zyada importance dene chahiye thi,
ise aap uski ek aur bahut badi ghalti maan sakte hain Bas,
khud hz ali ra ko dekh lijiye ki uski khilaafat ki kuch majbooriyon ne unhe na sirf hazrat usman ra ke qaatilon se aankhen band(close) karne par majboor kar diya balki use bade bade ohde dene pade, jabki hz usman ra ke qatl ka waqeya bhi kuch dardnaak aur yah gunaah bhi kuch kam darje kd na tha lekin iske bawajood hz ali ra unke khilaaf kuch na kar sake, yazid ne to hussain ra ke qaatilon ko unki commandari se sirf hataya hi nahi tha lekin hz ali ra ne to hz usman ra ke baad qaatilon ko bade bade ohdon se nawaaza,
yah waqeya agar hamare liye shakht dardnaak hai lekin is kya ilaaj ki " ahle sunnat" jab sahaba kiraam ra ke daur ko bhi bilkul shiat(rafziyat) ke chasme se dekhna shuru kar den to phir is ke bina chaara bhi nahi,
allah hamari in baton ko maaf farmaye...
Ye sawal pakistan me barelwi magazine RAZA E MUSTAFA(TAHIR UL QADRI) ka hai..... Jiska jawab ahle hadith islamic magazine AL EHTISHAM (salahuddin yousuf rh) walon ne diya....
Jisko shaikh salahuddin yousuf rh ki kitaab " MAHE MUHARRAM AUR MAUJOODA MUSALMAAN" me naqal kiya gaya hai
Aur sawalon ke jawab inshallah baad me post karenge....
SAWAL: Agar yazid ka ahle bait ke qatl me koi haanth nahi aur yah sab kuch ibne saad wa ibne ziyaad ki shararat hai to kya yazid ka yah farz nahi tha ki wah bahuqme apne governer etc ko bulaata aur unhe ahle bait ke qatal me wah ibne ziyad badmash ko commandari se hata sakta tha??
JAWAB: Yah sawal jayez hai yazid ko yaqinan hz hussain ra ke qaatilon se hisaab karna aur unhe commandari(status) se hata dena chahiye tha,
lekin jis tarah har baadshah ki kuch political majboorian hoti hain jin ke bina par kabhi kabhi unhe apne afsaron(officers) ki kuch aisi kaarywaayi(actions) se bhi aankhen moondni(closing) pad jaati hai, jinhe wah khud bhi ghalat samjhte hain, isi tarah ho sakta hai kuch aisi siyaasi majboori ho jisko yazid ne zyada importance de diya ho jabki use qatl hussain ko zyada importance dene chahiye thi,
ise aap uski ek aur bahut badi ghalti maan sakte hain Bas,
khud hz ali ra ko dekh lijiye ki uski khilaafat ki kuch majbooriyon ne unhe na sirf hazrat usman ra ke qaatilon se aankhen band(close) karne par majboor kar diya balki use bade bade ohde dene pade, jabki hz usman ra ke qatl ka waqeya bhi kuch dardnaak aur yah gunaah bhi kuch kam darje kd na tha lekin iske bawajood hz ali ra unke khilaaf kuch na kar sake, yazid ne to hussain ra ke qaatilon ko unki commandari se sirf hataya hi nahi tha lekin hz ali ra ne to hz usman ra ke baad qaatilon ko bade bade ohdon se nawaaza,
yah waqeya agar hamare liye shakht dardnaak hai lekin is kya ilaaj ki " ahle sunnat" jab sahaba kiraam ra ke daur ko bhi bilkul shiat(rafziyat) ke chasme se dekhna shuru kar den to phir is ke bina chaara bhi nahi,
allah hamari in baton ko maaf farmaye...
Ye sawal pakistan me barelwi magazine RAZA E MUSTAFA(TAHIR UL QADRI) ka hai..... Jiska jawab ahle hadith islamic magazine AL EHTISHAM (salahuddin yousuf rh) walon ne diya....
Jisko shaikh salahuddin yousuf rh ki kitaab " MAHE MUHARRAM AUR MAUJOODA MUSALMAAN" me naqal kiya gaya hai
Aur sawalon ke jawab inshallah baad me post karenge....
No comments:
Post a Comment